Report a Bug
#BugReportDecidim Let's test Decidim and report bugs together
Children assembly take into account on assemblies space
Withdrawn
Children assembly may not display on assemblies spaces. We expected to view that children inside the assembly.
v.0.13!
Proposal Withdrawn Reason
We are working to solve this incidence. You can follow the status here
Report inappropriate content
Is this content inappropriate?
7 comments
Conversation with Xabier
Hi @pau_coditramuntana can you explain better what do you expect should happen. I don't fully understand your bug report. Thanks!
When you are in assembly modul, you should see the whole active assemblies. But children assembly isn't an active assembly, is part of that. Same with process. If you have a group of process is because there's a one big process active and it childs takes part of it.
So imagine and organitzation that has its General Boarding. And then, created 10 child-assembly comissions inside the Assembly. It will be awfull and messy.
I think in previous versions participatory process worked like that
Ok, I understand now. I think we should consider this more carefully. Right now redundancy is better than hiding information, I mean, it is better to display "unnecessary" information than not displaying information. When you say: "So imagine and organitzation that has its General Boarding. And then, created 10 child-assembly commissions inside the Assembly. It will be awfull and messy. " I don't know why this would be awful and messy. It is often at the level of commissions that most activity takes place, this is actually true of most Assemblies. As a participant I might be more interested on directly accessing the child-assembly than the mother. Children assemblies ARE active assemblies.
I suggest to hold on this proposal and see how Assemblies are used (we don't have much experience with it yet, none with child-assemblies!) and consider making changes after we have some experience. What do you think @pau_coditramuntana ?
I think that we have differents points of view.
If I were a new user, I would like organized information (which not means hide information) rather than redudancy.
As you said, children assemblies are actives assemblies, but what happend if we close mother's one? In my opinion, it's mother assembly which give the children assembly active estatuts.
Maybe that's not a bug. So may I discard?
Hi @paarals I reply to myself because we have reached the limit of nested comments.
I understand what you are saying, and it makes a lot of sense. But consider that in many occasions it will be the case that there only on parent Assembly and all the rest might be children.
Should we not wait to see how this is deployed and then change the way in which assemblies are displayed?
I agree! So i'm gonna withdraw
We can come back to this when we have more experience with how Assemblies are used
Add your comment
Sign in with your account or sign up to add your comment.
Loading comments ...