Propose new functionalities for Decidim software
#DecidimRoadmap Designing Decidim together
Rejected
Is your feature request related to a problem? A clear and concise description of what the problem is.
As a admin it's frustrating to not be able to enable or disable comments on a single proposals / meeting.
Describe the solution you'd like
Adding an action in the admin to disable comments from the index instead of using permissions.
Describe alternatives you've considered
Set permissions to comment at the content level (proposal or meeting).
Does this issue could impact on users private data?
No
Funded by
EU Commission (COFE)
This proposal has been rejected because:
Please see comment
Related images
Report inappropriate content
Is this content inappropriate?
15 comments
By setting permissions I mean, when clicking on the 🔑 icon in the index of meeting and proposals (admin side)
Conversation with Ivan Vergés
@virgile_deville I think this is a duplicate of Restrict by verification to make comments
I think both proposals complement each other. This one disables comments completely, the one you posted disables comments for a specific set of users (those not verified).
Yes, I agree with Marc.
Conversation with Marc Riera
@virgile_deville @product does the suggested icon exist in the platform? http://decidim-design.herokuapp.com/public/library/pattern-library#patternIcons
Also, how would this work for Meetings? They already have a row with like 10 actions, are we adding a new one there?
Hello Marc,
The icon doesn't exist. Like the eye dashed from moderation I used the "CHAT" one and dashed it.
For meetings either we add yet another icon to the ten other or we do like proposals add select checkbox on the left and an action menu on the top : https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/11473995/98817521-7e3bb280-242a-11eb-86b7-e656ee9ca76d.png
Conversation with Marc Riera
Also, what about the content created by users (not from the admin but from the public area)? Should admins be able to disable comments for those resources too? @virgile_deville @product
bufff, delicate...
@valentin_osp do you know if the client has specified this ? I tend to think they want to be able to do it for all contents.
Conversation with Pau Parals
I don't agree with this feature. In my opinion, this will affect equal opportunities' social contract.
maybe there are some reasons which i can't see, but i imagine one controversial proposal (ie: management of water) created from citizens. If city council don't like this proposal, it has the power to disable comments (participatory washing) . I think that we have to focus on better moderation rather than avoid one way to deliberate.
I agree with you Pau. On another hand, an admin that doesn't like a debate has many way to stop a debate :
- unpublishing the component
- moderating the whole proposal rending debate impossible and hiding the whole content.
Yes, but in these cases it won't be shown in the public site so no "participatory washing" would be possible.
Yeah I agree.
Conversation with Carol Romero
Hey everyone, Sorry I'm late to the discussion.
I'm also sorry if there has been any misunderstanding between Codegram and OSP, but this feature is not approved by product nor will it be.
Probably because of the trolling often seen in corporate social networks, organizations think that this will happen in their instance of Decidim, and I don't deny that this possibility exists.
Now, with nearly 180 instances in production, there has not been a single case that requires either a priori moderation or measures such as this proposal. And I'm sure that if any of them had had serious problems, we would have heard about it. And *if the problem appears*, let's think about how to solve it in another way.
I think it is important that we have clear arguments when we are proposed this kind of features, especially by public institutions, since the bigger they are, the more they tend to this.
Thanks Carol for your feedback. On my end there were no misunderstanding. I created the proposal as requested by the EU Commission to see where the community stands. You answer is very clear thank you.
Add your comment
Sign in with your account or sign up to add your comment.
Loading comments ...